Do Children Really Make Us Happy?

23 weeks pregnant with Ryan - dreaming of the future

A couple of weeks ago, a friend of mine forwarded an article that she thought would be topical for my blog.  After reading it, I realized it was the perfect piece to complement what has been a running draft in my head for a while now. 

Over the past few months, I watched as our friends finally welcomed a daughter after several years of incredible heartbreak and loss.  I listened with chills as a family member recounted the day she got “the call” that a baby was born and that she and her husband were the couple chosen to adopt him.  I also had a great many conversations with first-time parents who felt isolated, guilty and confused as to why they tried for years to realize their dream of parenthood, only to find that in reality, their emotions didn’t come close to matching those expectations.

I am not going to quote the article (please read it – it’s quite interesting) but it centers on one woman’s purposeful decision not to have children as well as a national study which concludes that having children is inversely correlated with emotional well-being.  This study is counterintuitive as people have long thought that having a family is the key to a happy life, but this may not be the case as nearly 1 in 5 American women now end their childbearing years without having a child, according to U.S. Census data. 

I speak daily to seasoned parents who will readily admit that their children are the force behind most of their stress, who complain that there isn’t enough time in the day for their marriage or personal interests as a result of having children, but who also will enthusiastically agree that having children has been the single most wonderful thing they’ve ever done. 

It’s not surprising that parenthood causes more marital dissatisfaction, more personal dissatisfaction and less time for personal fulfillment.  Being a parent is a sacrifice, and not just for 18 years.  It is a full-time job, a constant cause for worry and a complete change of life from the one we enjoyed pre-parenthood.  Parenting is not for everyone, but for me, it is a deeper love than I’ve ever felt, a joy that I can’t explain and a feeling that my life is about something larger than myself. 

It wasn’t always that way, though.  As many of you know, eight days after Ryan’s birth, my life spun out of control.  My lifelong dream of motherhood did not nearly match the reality.  Ryan was not a difficult baby, he did not have medical issues, but my hormones, coupled with my family history of anxiety and depression, created a tornado of imbalance within my brain and resulted in a blackness (Postpartum Depression) that I wouldn’t wish on my worst enemy. 

Ryan the fetus at 30 weeks gestation

Everybody asks you if you’re blissfully in love with your baby.  Nobody asks you if the baby is colicky or if you’re feeling depressed or alone.

Everybody asks you how the baby sleeps.  Nobody asks you if you’re having trouble falling asleep.

Everybody asks you if you’re taking nice walks and enjoying these first few weeks.  Nobody asks you if you’re having trouble getting out of bed.

Nobody asks you if your husband is having a hard time adjusting to this new life. 

If you’re feeling trapped. 

If you feel a disconnect with your baby. 

Of course, many people make it through those first few months feeling tired but content, and are able to balance this new chapter with amazing grace.  But there are people like me who simply didn’t experience it like that. 

We didn’t understand how life would ever be the same.  Our marriages.  Our friendships.  Our time.  And it won’t be.  And it’s too scary to even speak aloud.  We didn’t yet know how fast our baby would smile and how that would make all the difference.  How a belly laugh would be the greatest sound in the world.  How sitting, standing and walking would come in stages and with each stage it gets better and better.  How we would fit into each other’s lives.  It didn’t come naturally to some of us. 

The article cites how parents in the U.S. lack the proper “support, child care and assistance” to raise a child.  How the government should “implement and subsidize more ‘kid-friendly’ policies to help families thrive”.  I agree.  We’ve long heard that it takes a village to raise a child.  In generations past, there were family members in close proximity and a sense of community that we rarely see today.  Parents today are more isolated than ever, family members are often spread throughout the country, there is an overwhelming amount of competition and judgment from other parents that is counterintuitive to what new parents need most – support.

My friend who sent the article shared her emotions from her first six months of motherhood.  She wrote,

“I like the take-home message that the parenting “ideal” doesn’t necessarily bring instant gratification of parental bliss. I wish someone had given me more of that realistic expectation up front, since I expected all instant happiness and smiles on Day 1 from a happy, smiling baby…when those smiles still take considerable effort to generate. Instead, for the first six months, I internalized it all as though I was doing something wrong, or not coping well enough as a new mom. At the six-month mark, an older family friend finally looked me in the eye and validated my feelings that, no, it’s not me, and yes, my baby is in fact a handful – even for a baby. From that single day of validation, I felt as though a veil lifted, as the sentiment alone was the emotional support I had needed all along.”   

This begs the question – why do we treat new mothers as if they have just won a prize?  Having a baby is surely cause for celebration – but those first few days and weeks are NOT a walk in the park and many times people forget that a newborn isn’t representative of the “family” you always dreamed of (in my case, I dreamed of family vacations with elementary-aged kids who walk and talk, not so much alien-looking newborns).  It’s not an automatic wish fulfilled – it’s a complete life-changer that turns everything you knew upside down and inside out.  Surely, the extra lumps and bumps left on our bodies, the lack of sleep, the new responsibilities, the shift in priorities, the milk leaking from our breasts and the sounds of crying that permeate our homes is enough to make you want to run away… so why is it that we shove these images aside and focus instead on a bliss and happiness that eludes most of us? 

32 weeks and blissfully happy

I will admit, the second time around I did not suffer Postpartum Depression and although I was tired and lumpy, leaking and hormonal, I already experienced what it was like to be a parent so it was not a shock to my system and I was happy and balanced.  Oh, plus I was on medication. 

But anyway, I think if we all gave new parents-to-be a little more of a realistic picture of those first weeks when they ask instead of suggesting they go to a movie and take naps now while they can, we would be doing them a great service. 

Yes, I do believe children make us happy.  But not necessarily right away.  And not necessarily every day.  Parenthood is not for everyone.  It is definitely a choice I am happy I made, but the happiness wasn’t automatic and it took a lot of work by me as a person, a wife and a Mom.  I slowly but surely found my way.  Let’s help our friends who are about to enter into this new phase of life see a more realistic picture of the happiness that is to come.

Share
  1. Marlee says:

    Well said Dani! I enjoy reading your blog.

  2. LB says:

    I enjoyed reading this D and agree with most of what you wrote however I’m not sure I could ever look a glowing pregnant friend/woman in the eye and admit to her how extremely tough and stressful this is. I say let her enjoy those nine months being blissfully unaware because you surely can never go back.

  3. Jessica says:

    Great question, do children make us happy? I think the answer is that it depends on what you put into it. There are so so so many things that the media romanticizes about childbirth and child rearing, and we dummies fall for it hook line and sinker… (just one example: I didn’t realize I was in labor and already almost 6 cm because it never looked the way it did on TV. My sis, who just happened to stop by and see my condition, dragged me to the hospital and I was so convinced she was wrong that I never even brought the bag that I so meticulously packed for weeks before!) And don’t even get me started on the utter horror that I felt when I realized that the hospital staff was actually going to let me leave, unattended and unsupervised, with my own BABY!!! 3.5 years later I am getting to a place of zen with motherhood, but it has honestly taken me that long to come to terms with the sheer amount of sacrifice the position demands. I loved him unconditionally from day 1, I was lucky not to have PPD but I got a very unhealthy dose of PMDD that lasted about 2 years. I stopped ovulating completely (long after I stopped breast feeding) because I honestly believe my brain said “no more!” and my body agreed. I thought more than once that my husband would leave us because, well, who would choose this life after being given the taste? After all, he wasn’t committed the way I was (still feel this to some degree). And I struggled and struggled with the complete loss of freedom, freedom I never realized I had until it was so unceremoniously taken away!! But it does and it did get better with time, and as much as I sometimes think that I might make a different choice if I had it to do over again, I know in my bones that I wouldn’t every single time this kid wraps those skinny little arms around my neck :)

  4. What an amazing post. I agree with some of your points. It’s not all sunshine and rainbows in the beginning. It takes time to kind of find your own personal motherhood groove. Nice and very honest post. Well done!

  5. mominrome says:

    GREAT POST!!

    Seing my belly get bigger and bigger was really something weird and spectacular at the same time!!

    :)

    Now I can’t wait to get rid of it though! :) I want to meet her !!!! :)
    mominrome\’s last post…My dog is a spinster

  6. Susan says:

    Great post Dani! A very honest and accurate look at new motherhood as many women experience it :)

  7. Lisa says:

    Dani, this is an absolutely beautiful post. Yet again, you’ve given eloquent words to what so many of us think and feel. The scariest part of all, to me, is that for the first six weeks postpartum, there is no medical mechanism to “catch” the women who really need medical and/or psychological intervention. Sure, there are pediatric check-ups and the all-important six week postpartum check-up for the physical well-being of the mother, but how do you help the PPD women out there unless they self-identify? For all the medical support throughout a pregnancy, the medical care for women drops off a cliff as soon as you leave the hospital unless there is an actual problem. To me, this is one huge area that the U.S. system could use drastic improvement.

  8. mariana says:

    Dani, you have opened up a very important dialogue about what it truly means when one says, ” I want to have a family.” Having children is the most difficult task in the world and requires open communication and extraordinary strength between the man and woman prior to and during marriage. Recently, my only and youngest sister had a baby. Both my sister and bro-in-law work full time and had no choice but to hire a nanny. This wasn’t their ideal choice but were left with no other options. They have both expressed their thoughts on what having a child has meant and would both agree that they knew it would be hard, but not this hard! Luckily, they have an incredible relationship and are both 110% percent dedicated. On the flip side, I have friends who’s marriages have suffered tremendously and are on the brink.

    I can personally relate to this article as I have always known that motherhood wasn’t for me. I am fully aware that not everyone is able to make these determinations based on many factors. I also believe that it’s up to each individual to make decisions that they feel is best for them. My hat goes off to all the mothers and fathers out there!!!! You are all the most remarkable people and don’t know how ya’ll do it!!!!

  9. Hi, Dani. Thanks for visiting my blog the other day.

    I am so glad you wrote this. I feel like I am the only mother on earth who did not like being pregnant and didn’t much care for the first two years of my children’s lives. I was loving and supportive, but it was so emotionally and physically draining on me. It wasn’t until the kids got older that I felt I really “tapped” in to motherhood as I was meant to.

Leave a Reply

  Some XHTML allowed.  

CommentLuv badge
Princessories by Playing Mom Follow Me on Pinterest Princessories by Playing Mom Photobucket NY Moms World